that doesn't work because you do'nt know if the odd ball is heavier or lighter.
the trick is to switch.
put four on each side. (first pass) if the scale is balanced, the odd ball is in the remaining four.
switch one from each side: if the scale remains unbalanced the same way, the odd ball is in the two that were not switched. (second pass) if the scale changes balance, the odd ball is one of the two that were switched. in either case, discard the other two.
change one of the balls for one of the discarded ones to find out if the odd ball is heavier or lighter (ie, if the scale balances, the ball switched off was the odd one and you can tell if it was heavier or lighter; if the scale does not balance, the remaining ball is the odd one and the scale will reveal if it's heavier or lighter than the ball used to compare).
let's assume in step one that the scales did not balance - that means that the odd ball is one of the eight on the scales (disregard the four remaining). switch three from each side (second pass). if the scales remained unbalanced the same way, then the odd ball is in the balls that were not switched. compare one side with one of the discarded balls to figure out which one it is. (third pass)
.... and that's as far as i can go without my brain overheating, lol.